The New Floor for Truckload Rates: Why Carrier Economics Point to Sustained Rate Increases
Carrier costs are up 28% since 2018 and truckload margins sit at 0.4%. Here is why NTG expects both spot and contract rates to keep rising.
Key takeaways
- The cost of operating a truck has risen more than 28% since 2018, and non-fuel costs have risen nearly 34%, according to ATRI.
- Truckload carriers averaged a 0.4% operating margin in 2025, a level that cannot sustain an asset-intensive business.
- Recent spot rate gains have been driven largely by fuel, not by a recovery in underlying carrier economics.
- Driver wages, equipment, insurance and fuel all point higher, with little reason to expect relief.
- NTG’s position: spot and contract rates are entering a sustained upward pricing cycle.
Since 2018, the cost of operating a truck has increased more than 28%, according to ATRI, while non-fuel operating costs have risen nearly 34%. Over that same period, carriers have faced a prolonged freight recession, deteriorating profitability and rates that have failed to keep pace with the underlying cost of operating their businesses.
Carrier economics
The cost to operate a truck, 2018 to 2025
Industry-average cost per mile. Fuel swings the all-in line; costs excluding fuel have risen every year since 2020.
Source: American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking, 2019 to 2026 editions. All-in includes fuel; excluding fuel removes ATRI’s fuel cost per mile. Excluding-fuel values for 2018 ($1.821 minus 43.3 cents), 2019 ($1.652 minus 39.6 cents) and 2022 ($2.251 minus 64.1 cents) are calculated from ATRI’s published figures; ATRI reports 2020, 2021 and 2023 to 2025 directly.
View the data table
| Year | All-in cost per mile | Excluding fuel |
|---|---|---|
| 2018 | $1.821 | $1.388 |
| 2019 | $1.652 | $1.256 |
| 2020 | $1.646 | $1.338 |
| 2021 | $1.855 | $1.438 |
| 2022 | $2.251 | $1.610 |
| 2023 | $2.270 | $1.716 |
| 2024 | $2.260 | $1.779 |
| 2025 | $2.336 | $1.854 |
Are truckload rates finally rising?
Yes, but not for the reasons that would fix carrier economics. DAT data shows that spot rates are finally moving higher, but the recent increases have not fully addressed the structural cost pressures facing carriers. Fuel has contributed significantly to higher all-in rates, while the underlying economics of operating a trucking company remain challenging.
In September 2026, the national average dry van spot rate rose 12 cents per mile from August while its linehaul portion fell 2 cents, as diesel averaged a record $6.291 per gallon, according to DAT.
Why won’t carrier operating costs come back down?
Looking ahead, there is little reason to expect these costs to reverse:
- Driver wages will need to increase as demand strengthens and competition for qualified drivers returns. ATRI found driver wages rose 2.5% in 2025, below the 2.7% inflation rate, for the second consecutive year.
- Equipment acquisition and replacement costs remain elevated, with tariffs and inflation creating additional upward pressure.
- Insurance costs continue to increase, adding to an already significant financial burden. ATRI’s first-quarter 2026 data shows truck insurance premiums per mile running 6.4% above the 2025 average.
- Fuel costs remain volatile and elevated, with limited visibility into meaningful long-term relief.
- Carrier operating margins remain unsustainably low, leaving little opportunity to reinvest in equipment, drivers and business operations.
Early 2026 signal
Costs kept rising into 2026
Change in cost per mile, first quarter 2026 versus the 2025 average, selected line items.
Source: American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking, 2026 update (first-quarter 2026 financial data), as reported by Heavy Duty Trucking and FleetOwner. ATRI reported that most other categories rose about 2%, while driver wages and truck and trailer costs decelerated.
View the data table
| Line item | Q1 2026 vs. 2025 average |
|---|---|
| Truck insurance premiums | +6.4% |
| Fuel | +5.9% |
| Driver benefits | +4.5% |
| Tolls | +2.7% |
| Tires | -4.8% |
For a line-by-line view of how these costs reach the rates shippers pay, see why rates rise when truck operating costs increase.
Why is a 0.4% operating margin unsustainable for truckload carriers?
ATRI reported average truckload operating margins of just 0.4% in 2025. This is not a sustainable economic model for an asset-intensive industry.
At that margin, a carrier keeps less than half a cent of every dollar in revenue after covering the cost of trucks, trailers, drivers, insurance and fuel. That leaves almost nothing to replace aging equipment, raise driver pay or absorb the next cost increase.
Carrier profitability
What a 0.4% operating margin leaves a carrier
Average carrier operating margin, truckload by year and by truckload-type sector in 2025. Truckload is highlighted.
$10 million in revenue
Source: American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), Analysis of the Operational Costs of Trucking, 2024, 2025 and 2026 editions, as reported by Transport Topics and FreightWaves. ATRI reported the 2022 and 2023 truckload margins as whole percentages. Operating income shown is revenue multiplied by the average margin; individual carriers vary.
View the data table
| Measure | Average operating margin |
|---|---|
| Truckload, 2022 | 8% |
| Truckload, 2023 | 3% |
| Truckload, 2024 | -2.3% |
| Truckload, 2025 | 0.4% |
| Tank, 2025 | 4.0% |
| Refrigerated, 2025 | 0.6% |
| Flatbed, 2025 | -0.5% |
What happens to truckload capacity when carriers cannot earn a return?
Carriers cannot continue absorbing higher operating costs while accepting returns that fail to justify the capital invested in their businesses. Those unable to generate sufficient profitability will reduce capacity or exit the market. As capacity contracts and demand stabilizes, pricing power will increasingly shift toward carriers.
That contraction is already underway. ATRI found that carriers cut average truck counts by 2.4% in 2025, their largest capacity reduction since the freight recession began in 2022, and left about 10% of trucks unseated, meaning without a driver.
Where are truckload rates headed?
Our position is that both spot and contract rates are entering a sustained upward pricing cycle. The question is not whether rates will increase, but how quickly they will rise and how much additional capacity will leave the market before carrier economics return to sustainable levels.
The freight recession may have delayed the inevitable, but it did not eliminate eight years of cost inflation. Carriers cannot operate indefinitely without earning an adequate return. Rates must rise, or capacity will continue to disappear until they do.
Frequently asked questions
What was the average truckload operating margin in 2025?
Truckload carriers averaged a 0.4% operating margin in 2025, up from a 2.3% operating loss in 2024, according to ATRI. Refrigerated carriers averaged 0.6%, tank carriers 4.0%, and flatbed carriers posted a 0.5% loss.
Will truckload rates go down in 2027?
NTG does not expect a meaningful decline. Driver wages, equipment, insurance and fuel all face upward pressure, and carriers are already shrinking fleets because current rates do not cover a sustainable return. Short-term swings will occur with fuel and seasonality, but the cost floor beneath rates is higher than it was before the freight recession.
Will contract rates rise along with spot rates?
NTG expects both spot and contract rates to move higher. Spot rates typically respond first as capacity tightens. Contract rates follow as bids reset and carriers decline freight that does not cover their cost of operation.
Planning for 2027
Budget for the market that is coming, not the one that is ending
If your next truckload bid or budget assumes freight-recession pricing, it is worth a second look. An NTG representative can review your lanes against current spot and contract conditions.
- See where your current rates sit against today’s market on your key lanes
- Decide which lanes to lock in under contract and which to keep flexible on spot
- Get truckload and LTL quotes with an NTG representative to support you

On this page:
Subscribe to our Newsletter